媽媽嘴案判老闆連帶賠償368萬 最高法院 - 法律
By Olive
at 2017-06-23T08:20
at 2017-06-23T08:20
Table of Contents
※ [本文轉錄自 Gossiping 看板 #1PIw7v1H ]
作者: shiwenli (阿爸) 看板: Gossiping
標題: [新聞] 媽媽嘴案判老闆連帶賠償368萬 最高法院
時間: Thu Jun 22 18:54:45 2017
媽媽嘴案判老闆連帶賠償368萬 最高法院5理由說明
2017-06-22 18:23聯合報 記者蘇位榮╱即時報導
喧騰一時的「媽媽嘴」八里雙屍命案日前定讞，除了殺人的女店長謝依涵遭判刑外，老闆
呂炳宏等3名股東也被判處連帶賠償被害人張翠萍母親368萬餘元，引起輿論譁然，最高法
院今天發出新聞稿再度說明何以判決呂炳宏等3名股東要與謝依涵連帶賠償。
最高法院提出5項理由如下：
一，一般顧客到咖啡店消費，是相信可在安全無虞環境消費，身任店長為顧客準備飲品，
是謝依涵的職務範圍，謝將安眠藥摻入陳進福夫妻於該店所點選飲品，行為外觀上具有執
行職務形式，且該店亦為其執行職務地點，客觀上可認謝依涵係在執行職務，不能以陳進
福夫妻生命遭侵害之地點係在淡水河邊紅樹林，不在咖啡店內，就認為與謝依涵執行職務
無關。
二，呂炳宏等人合資經營媽媽嘴咖啡店雖有員工教育手冊，但手冊並無關於顧客消費及場
所安全的注意事項。店員於當晚7點半左右已發現陳進福神情昏沈，臉色難看，卻未予關
心，提供協助，亦未通報當時在辦公室內呂炳宏，甚至於晚間8點半再到客人用餐區，看
到陳進福仍緊閉雙眼坐在座位上，仍未理會，致錯失兩次避免不幸事件發生機會，可見呂
炳宏等人經營媽媽嘴咖啡店對於顧客在店內發生狀況，或身體不適時應如何處理，並無建
制一套通報及處理流程，亦未對於店長及其他員工，有無適時處理顧客身體異常狀況，建
立監督機制。
三，依照呂炳宏陳述，謝依涵上班原穿短裙搭配內搭褲，當晚呂炳宏看到謝依涵更換運動
長褲，詢其原因僅答稱學跳水，並未注意查詢謝依涵於工作中離開咖啡店在外落水，顯見
媽媽嘴咖啡店對於身為最資深者或店長的謝依涵，於工作中離開咖啡店，亦無管理監督機
制，讓謝依涵得以從容將陷於意識不清、不能抗拒狀態的陳進福扶出店外殺害，媽媽嘴咖
啡店對於謝依涵之監督未盡相當注意義務，所以無法免除呂炳宏等人所應負僱用人責任。
四，民法第188條第1項所謂僱用人與受雇人負連帶賠償責任，是就受僱人因執行職務不法
侵害他人權利而言，只要受僱人在客觀上足認與其執行職務有關行為在內，均屬於執行職
務，這樣才可以保護第三人之權利，使第三人有獲得賠償機會，不能將謝依涵在媽媽嘴咖
啡店將安眠藥加入咖啡，讓陳進福夫妻飲用，使其意識不清的行為，與後來謝將其扶至店
外殺害行為予以分開為兩個個別行為。
民法第188條所以規定僱用人應對於受僱人因執行職務不法侵害他人權利行為，負連帶賠
償責任，是因為僱用人藉由受僱人為其工作，因而擴大或延伸其活動範圍，僱用人自應就
其選任監督受僱人負注意義務，以預防受僱人在工作時發生侵害他人權利情事，注意範圍
包括受僱人性格、操守等。
五，判決呂炳宏等人應負僱用人賠償責任，不是因為他們未檢查謝依涵為顧客所準備飲品
是否安全，而是因為他們對謝依涵未盡到選任及監督注意義務，所以必須對於謝依涵侵害
顧客行為負責。
至於呂炳宏等人曾遭謝依涵誣陷為共犯，僅屬呂炳宏等人與謝依涵的內部關係，與呂炳宏
等人應對第三人負僱用人賠償責任，係屬二事，不應混為一談。
https://udn.com/news/story/7321/2540491?from=udn-ch1_breaknews-1-0-news
--
作者: shiwenli (阿爸) 看板: Gossiping
標題: [新聞] 媽媽嘴案判老闆連帶賠償368萬 最高法院
時間: Thu Jun 22 18:54:45 2017
媽媽嘴案判老闆連帶賠償368萬 最高法院5理由說明
2017-06-22 18:23聯合報 記者蘇位榮╱即時報導
喧騰一時的「媽媽嘴」八里雙屍命案日前定讞，除了殺人的女店長謝依涵遭判刑外，老闆
呂炳宏等3名股東也被判處連帶賠償被害人張翠萍母親368萬餘元，引起輿論譁然，最高法
院今天發出新聞稿再度說明何以判決呂炳宏等3名股東要與謝依涵連帶賠償。
最高法院提出5項理由如下：
一，一般顧客到咖啡店消費，是相信可在安全無虞環境消費，身任店長為顧客準備飲品，
是謝依涵的職務範圍，謝將安眠藥摻入陳進福夫妻於該店所點選飲品，行為外觀上具有執
行職務形式，且該店亦為其執行職務地點，客觀上可認謝依涵係在執行職務，不能以陳進
福夫妻生命遭侵害之地點係在淡水河邊紅樹林，不在咖啡店內，就認為與謝依涵執行職務
無關。
二，呂炳宏等人合資經營媽媽嘴咖啡店雖有員工教育手冊，但手冊並無關於顧客消費及場
所安全的注意事項。店員於當晚7點半左右已發現陳進福神情昏沈，臉色難看，卻未予關
心，提供協助，亦未通報當時在辦公室內呂炳宏，甚至於晚間8點半再到客人用餐區，看
到陳進福仍緊閉雙眼坐在座位上，仍未理會，致錯失兩次避免不幸事件發生機會，可見呂
炳宏等人經營媽媽嘴咖啡店對於顧客在店內發生狀況，或身體不適時應如何處理，並無建
制一套通報及處理流程，亦未對於店長及其他員工，有無適時處理顧客身體異常狀況，建
立監督機制。
三，依照呂炳宏陳述，謝依涵上班原穿短裙搭配內搭褲，當晚呂炳宏看到謝依涵更換運動
長褲，詢其原因僅答稱學跳水，並未注意查詢謝依涵於工作中離開咖啡店在外落水，顯見
媽媽嘴咖啡店對於身為最資深者或店長的謝依涵，於工作中離開咖啡店，亦無管理監督機
制，讓謝依涵得以從容將陷於意識不清、不能抗拒狀態的陳進福扶出店外殺害，媽媽嘴咖
啡店對於謝依涵之監督未盡相當注意義務，所以無法免除呂炳宏等人所應負僱用人責任。
四，民法第188條第1項所謂僱用人與受雇人負連帶賠償責任，是就受僱人因執行職務不法
侵害他人權利而言，只要受僱人在客觀上足認與其執行職務有關行為在內，均屬於執行職
務，這樣才可以保護第三人之權利，使第三人有獲得賠償機會，不能將謝依涵在媽媽嘴咖
啡店將安眠藥加入咖啡，讓陳進福夫妻飲用，使其意識不清的行為，與後來謝將其扶至店
外殺害行為予以分開為兩個個別行為。
民法第188條所以規定僱用人應對於受僱人因執行職務不法侵害他人權利行為，負連帶賠
償責任，是因為僱用人藉由受僱人為其工作，因而擴大或延伸其活動範圍，僱用人自應就
其選任監督受僱人負注意義務，以預防受僱人在工作時發生侵害他人權利情事，注意範圍
包括受僱人性格、操守等。
五，判決呂炳宏等人應負僱用人賠償責任，不是因為他們未檢查謝依涵為顧客所準備飲品
是否安全，而是因為他們對謝依涵未盡到選任及監督注意義務，所以必須對於謝依涵侵害
顧客行為負責。
至於呂炳宏等人曾遭謝依涵誣陷為共犯，僅屬呂炳宏等人與謝依涵的內部關係，與呂炳宏
等人應對第三人負僱用人賠償責任，係屬二事，不應混為一談。
https://udn.com/news/story/7321/2540491?from=udn-ch1_breaknews-1-0-news
--
Tags:
法律
All Comments
By George
at 2017-06-27T18:51
at 2017-06-27T18:51
By Daph Bay
at 2017-06-29T22:22
at 2017-06-29T22:22
By Daniel
at 2017-07-01T02:50
at 2017-07-01T02:50
By Caitlin
at 2017-07-02T00:07
at 2017-07-02T00:07
By Ina
at 2017-07-02T18:26
at 2017-07-02T18:26
By Catherine
at 2017-07-04T17:48
at 2017-07-04T17:48
By Anthony
at 2017-07-09T10:02
at 2017-07-09T10:02
By Sarah
at 2017-07-14T00:08
at 2017-07-14T00:08
By Xanthe
at 2017-07-16T11:44
at 2017-07-16T11:44
By Mia
at 2017-07-20T08:53
at 2017-07-20T08:53
By Necoo
at 2017-07-25T05:01
at 2017-07-25T05:01
By Rebecca
at 2017-07-28T00:22
at 2017-07-28T00:22
By Sarah
at 2017-08-01T18:01
at 2017-08-01T18:01
By Hedy
at 2017-08-06T05:20
at 2017-08-06T05:20
By Hedy
at 2017-08-09T04:29
at 2017-08-09T04:29
By Queena
at 2017-08-11T13:12
at 2017-08-11T13:12
By Caroline
at 2017-08-12T03:55
at 2017-08-12T03:55
By Eden
at 2017-08-13T16:20
at 2017-08-13T16:20
By Skylar DavisLinda
at 2017-08-14T01:42
at 2017-08-14T01:42
By Christine
at 2017-08-18T07:57
at 2017-08-18T07:57
By Hedy
at 2017-08-20T03:37
at 2017-08-20T03:37
By Puput
at 2017-08-23T04:08
at 2017-08-23T04:08
By Carolina Franco
at 2017-08-26T00:48
at 2017-08-26T00:48
By Delia
at 2017-08-29T22:56
at 2017-08-29T22:56
By Bethany
at 2017-09-02T22:13
at 2017-09-02T22:13
By Rosalind
at 2017-09-06T01:21
at 2017-09-06T01:21
By Carolina Franco
at 2017-09-10T04:44
at 2017-09-10T04:44
By Charlotte
at 2017-09-12T21:14
at 2017-09-12T21:14
By Una
at 2017-09-16T09:59
at 2017-09-16T09:59
By Delia
at 2017-09-20T13:24
at 2017-09-20T13:24
By Isla
at 2017-09-24T20:47
at 2017-09-24T20:47
By Wallis
at 2017-09-29T15:14
at 2017-09-29T15:14
By Donna
at 2017-09-30T04:50
at 2017-09-30T04:50
By Tristan Cohan
at 2017-10-02T06:02
at 2017-10-02T06:02
By Tristan Cohan
at 2017-10-02T13:12
at 2017-10-02T13:12
By Freda
at 2017-10-07T01:10
at 2017-10-07T01:10
By Heather
at 2017-10-10T17:55
at 2017-10-10T17:55
By Isabella
at 2017-10-11T20:10
at 2017-10-11T20:10
By Jack
at 2017-10-12T06:49
at 2017-10-12T06:49
By Rachel
at 2017-10-15T04:56
at 2017-10-15T04:56
By Margaret
at 2017-10-16T06:48
at 2017-10-16T06:48
By Lucy
at 2017-10-17T04:46
at 2017-10-17T04:46
By Jacob
at 2017-10-19T05:39
at 2017-10-19T05:39
By Quanna
at 2017-10-21T00:59
at 2017-10-21T00:59
By Xanthe
at 2017-10-25T23:27
at 2017-10-25T23:27
By Isla
at 2017-10-26T00:30
at 2017-10-26T00:30
By Harry
at 2017-10-28T04:48
at 2017-10-28T04:48
By Carol
at 2017-10-30T18:57
at 2017-10-30T18:57
By Isla
at 2017-11-02T02:31
at 2017-11-02T02:31
By Charlotte
at 2017-11-06T12:09
at 2017-11-06T12:09
By Xanthe
at 2017-11-10T15:47
at 2017-11-10T15:47
By Hedy
at 2017-11-13T18:19
at 2017-11-13T18:19
By Necoo
at 2017-11-17T12:16
at 2017-11-17T12:16
By Harry
at 2017-11-20T16:28
at 2017-11-20T16:28
By Robert
at 2017-11-21T21:52
at 2017-11-21T21:52
By Quanna
at 2017-11-22T07:13
at 2017-11-22T07:13
By Hedwig
at 2017-11-22T20:42
at 2017-11-22T20:42
By Una
at 2017-11-27T04:14
at 2017-11-27T04:14
By Steve
at 2017-11-28T13:07
at 2017-11-28T13:07
By Bethany
at 2017-11-29T04:54
at 2017-11-29T04:54
By Zenobia
at 2017-12-01T23:35
at 2017-12-01T23:35
By Franklin
at 2017-12-02T12:08
at 2017-12-02T12:08
By Sandy
at 2017-12-02T20:06
at 2017-12-02T20:06
By Frederic
at 2017-12-03T00:26
at 2017-12-03T00:26
By Rosalind
at 2017-12-04T22:11
at 2017-12-04T22:11
By Oliver
at 2017-12-08T15:00
at 2017-12-08T15:00
By Joseph
at 2017-12-09T16:56
at 2017-12-09T16:56
By Margaret
at 2017-12-11T12:39
at 2017-12-11T12:39
By Thomas
at 2017-12-12T06:56
at 2017-12-12T06:56
By Yedda
at 2017-12-12T18:24
at 2017-12-12T18:24
By Jacob
at 2017-12-13T12:43
at 2017-12-13T12:43
By Caitlin
at 2017-12-17T05:26
at 2017-12-17T05:26
By Victoria
at 2017-12-19T09:31
at 2017-12-19T09:31
By Regina
at 2017-12-20T18:59
at 2017-12-20T18:59
By Jack
at 2017-12-23T03:36
at 2017-12-23T03:36
By Michael
at 2017-12-27T21:14
at 2017-12-27T21:14
By Xanthe
at 2018-01-01T18:28
at 2018-01-01T18:28
By Annie
at 2018-01-04T14:01
at 2018-01-04T14:01
By Blanche
at 2018-01-04T15:12
at 2018-01-04T15:12
By David
at 2018-01-07T22:02
at 2018-01-07T22:02
By Joe
at 2018-01-09T18:27
at 2018-01-09T18:27
By Susan
at 2018-01-13T22:01
at 2018-01-13T22:01
By Skylar DavisLinda
at 2018-01-16T14:06
at 2018-01-16T14:06
By Ula
at 2018-01-18T19:57
at 2018-01-18T19:57
By Connor
at 2018-01-20T16:48
at 2018-01-20T16:48
By Jacky
at 2018-01-25T09:03
at 2018-01-25T09:03
By Caitlin
at 2018-01-26T22:01
at 2018-01-26T22:01
By Lauren
at 2018-01-28T02:55
at 2018-01-28T02:55
By Ethan
at 2018-01-29T14:03
at 2018-01-29T14:03
By Hamiltion
at 2018-01-31T19:42
at 2018-01-31T19:42
By Xanthe
at 2018-02-01T23:50
at 2018-02-01T23:50
By Rachel
at 2018-02-05T15:48
at 2018-02-05T15:48
By Jack
at 2018-02-08T20:12
at 2018-02-08T20:12
By Audriana
at 2018-02-10T07:02
at 2018-02-10T07:02
By Hedda
at 2018-02-12T09:12
at 2018-02-12T09:12
By Carol
at 2018-02-14T12:41
at 2018-02-14T12:41
By Selena
at 2018-02-16T23:16
at 2018-02-16T23:16
By Frederic
at 2018-02-18T04:22
at 2018-02-18T04:22
By Ina
at 2018-02-21T13:14
at 2018-02-21T13:14
By Odelette
at 2018-02-26T02:58
at 2018-02-26T02:58
By Thomas
at 2018-02-26T05:57
at 2018-02-26T05:57
By Lydia
at 2018-03-02T06:48
at 2018-03-02T06:48
By Aaliyah
at 2018-03-02T12:26
at 2018-03-02T12:26
By Lily
at 2018-03-05T10:37
at 2018-03-05T10:37
By Rae
at 2018-03-05T20:35
at 2018-03-05T20:35
By Anthony
at 2018-03-08T14:50
at 2018-03-08T14:50
By Delia
at 2018-03-12T20:42
at 2018-03-12T20:42
By Doris
at 2018-03-14T16:12
at 2018-03-14T16:12
By Mia
at 2018-03-14T20:59
at 2018-03-14T20:59
By Andrew
at 2018-03-15T15:18
at 2018-03-15T15:18
By Enid
at 2018-03-20T08:02
at 2018-03-20T08:02
By Belly
at 2018-03-23T17:45
at 2018-03-23T17:45
By Zenobia
at 2018-03-24T01:36
at 2018-03-24T01:36
By Lauren
at 2018-03-24T05:21
at 2018-03-24T05:21
By Thomas
at 2018-03-28T16:02
at 2018-03-28T16:02
By Hazel
at 2018-03-28T21:44
at 2018-03-28T21:44
By Bennie
at 2018-03-31T14:53
at 2018-03-31T14:53
By Linda
at 2018-04-02T15:24
at 2018-04-02T15:24
By Sierra Rose
at 2018-04-06T01:10
at 2018-04-06T01:10
By Susan
at 2018-04-07T05:16
at 2018-04-07T05:16
By Skylar Davis
at 2018-04-10T04:43
at 2018-04-10T04:43
By Emma
at 2018-04-11T07:45
at 2018-04-11T07:45
By Daniel
at 2018-04-16T02:13
at 2018-04-16T02:13
By Daniel
at 2018-04-19T03:09
at 2018-04-19T03:09
By Genevieve
at 2018-04-22T18:44
at 2018-04-22T18:44
By George
at 2018-04-23T18:21
at 2018-04-23T18:21
By Carolina Franco
at 2018-04-27T08:46
at 2018-04-27T08:46
By Ethan
at 2018-04-30T14:26
at 2018-04-30T14:26
By Carolina Franco
at 2018-05-02T09:17
at 2018-05-02T09:17
By Ophelia
at 2018-05-06T16:01
at 2018-05-06T16:01
By Wallis
at 2018-05-08T17:24
at 2018-05-08T17:24
By Valerie
at 2018-05-09T12:37
at 2018-05-09T12:37
By Ophelia
at 2018-05-12T13:56
at 2018-05-12T13:56
By Eden
at 2018-05-13T10:32
at 2018-05-13T10:32
By Hamiltion
at 2018-05-14T08:57
at 2018-05-14T08:57
By William
at 2018-05-16T04:48
at 2018-05-16T04:48
By Una
at 2018-05-20T00:03
at 2018-05-20T00:03
By Doris
at 2018-05-24T12:20
at 2018-05-24T12:20
By Robert
at 2018-05-25T15:54
at 2018-05-25T15:54
By Daph Bay
at 2018-05-27T04:10
at 2018-05-27T04:10
By Madame
at 2018-05-31T09:11
at 2018-05-31T09:11
By Audriana
at 2018-06-02T11:24
at 2018-06-02T11:24
By Regina
at 2018-06-03T22:05
at 2018-06-03T22:05
By Andy
at 2018-06-07T01:46
at 2018-06-07T01:46
By Zanna
at 2018-06-11T16:37
at 2018-06-11T16:37
By Kumar
at 2018-06-12T12:59
at 2018-06-12T12:59
By Emma
at 2018-06-14T18:39
at 2018-06-14T18:39
By Dora
at 2018-06-14T21:16
at 2018-06-14T21:16
By Mia
at 2018-06-17T14:20
at 2018-06-17T14:20
By Adele
at 2018-06-17T21:44
at 2018-06-17T21:44
By Brianna
at 2018-06-18T11:11
at 2018-06-18T11:11
By David
at 2018-06-18T13:27
at 2018-06-18T13:27
By Blanche
at 2018-06-21T13:13
at 2018-06-21T13:13
By Odelette
at 2018-06-22T12:28
at 2018-06-22T12:28
By Blanche
at 2018-06-24T10:10
at 2018-06-24T10:10
By Charlie
at 2018-06-26T14:24
at 2018-06-26T14:24
By Sandy
at 2018-06-27T09:08
at 2018-06-27T09:08
By Gilbert
at 2018-07-01T14:13
at 2018-07-01T14:13
By David
at 2018-07-03T21:34
at 2018-07-03T21:34
By Lauren
at 2018-07-07T05:26
at 2018-07-07T05:26
By Ina
at 2018-07-11T14:26
at 2018-07-11T14:26
By Delia
at 2018-07-15T19:47
at 2018-07-15T19:47
By Zenobia
at 2018-07-16T16:23
at 2018-07-16T16:23
By Gilbert
at 2018-07-19T01:33
at 2018-07-19T01:33
By David
at 2018-07-20T23:24
at 2018-07-20T23:24
By Gilbert
at 2018-07-25T00:23
at 2018-07-25T00:23
By Una
at 2018-07-28T16:43
at 2018-07-28T16:43
By Kama
at 2018-07-31T18:11
at 2018-07-31T18:11
By Todd Johnson
at 2018-08-01T13:20
at 2018-08-01T13:20
By Hardy
at 2018-08-06T07:11
at 2018-08-06T07:11
By Olivia
at 2018-08-06T17:14
at 2018-08-06T17:14
By Charlie
at 2018-08-07T02:53
at 2018-08-07T02:53
By Rosalind
at 2018-08-08T00:07
at 2018-08-08T00:07
By Selena
at 2018-08-10T21:18
at 2018-08-10T21:18
By Hamiltion
at 2018-08-15T03:41
at 2018-08-15T03:41
By Sierra Rose
at 2018-08-16T08:49
at 2018-08-16T08:49
By Barb Cronin
at 2018-08-20T01:36
at 2018-08-20T01:36
By Audriana
at 2018-08-20T04:49
at 2018-08-20T04:49
By Audriana
at 2018-08-23T17:09
at 2018-08-23T17:09
By Carol
at 2018-08-28T09:14
at 2018-08-28T09:14
By Anonymous
at 2018-09-01T09:52
at 2018-09-01T09:52
By Skylar Davis
at 2018-09-02T06:47
at 2018-09-02T06:47
By Hedwig
at 2018-09-02T19:14
at 2018-09-02T19:14
By Hedy
at 2018-09-04T18:11
at 2018-09-04T18:11
By Olga
at 2018-09-08T09:52
at 2018-09-08T09:52
By Audriana
at 2018-09-11T00:42
at 2018-09-11T00:42
By Callum
at 2018-09-11T16:32
at 2018-09-11T16:32
By Xanthe
at 2018-09-13T23:44
at 2018-09-13T23:44
By Erin
at 2018-09-18T22:43
at 2018-09-18T22:43
By Heather
at 2018-09-20T20:17
at 2018-09-20T20:17
By Belly
at 2018-09-24T01:37
at 2018-09-24T01:37
By Kama
at 2018-09-24T07:41
at 2018-09-24T07:41
By Jacob
at 2018-09-25T14:09
at 2018-09-25T14:09
By Oscar
at 2018-09-26T23:21
at 2018-09-26T23:21
By Gary
at 2018-10-01T02:35
at 2018-10-01T02:35
By Dorothy
at 2018-10-04T08:11
at 2018-10-04T08:11
By Kumar
at 2018-10-04T14:10
at 2018-10-04T14:10
By Catherine
at 2018-10-06T20:44
at 2018-10-06T20:44
By Tom
at 2018-10-11T08:37
at 2018-10-11T08:37
By Ida
at 2018-10-13T22:57
at 2018-10-13T22:57
By Valerie
at 2018-10-16T10:11
at 2018-10-16T10:11
By Kyle
at 2018-10-20T08:51
at 2018-10-20T08:51
By Catherine
at 2018-10-20T13:28
at 2018-10-20T13:28
By David
at 2018-10-24T15:09
at 2018-10-24T15:09
By David
at 2018-10-28T07:23
at 2018-10-28T07:23
By Ula
at 2018-10-31T03:34
at 2018-10-31T03:34
By Kumar
at 2018-11-02T09:49
at 2018-11-02T09:49
By Dorothy
at 2018-11-05T05:31
at 2018-11-05T05:31
By Barb Cronin
at 2018-11-07T18:49
at 2018-11-07T18:49
By Margaret
at 2018-11-09T03:19
at 2018-11-09T03:19
By Rebecca
at 2018-11-13T07:28
at 2018-11-13T07:28
By Lauren
at 2018-11-14T23:18
at 2018-11-14T23:18
By Agatha
at 2018-11-18T09:41
at 2018-11-18T09:41
By Faithe
at 2018-11-19T14:16
at 2018-11-19T14:16
By Brianna
at 2018-11-21T14:51
at 2018-11-21T14:51
By Hamiltion
at 2018-11-24T10:58
at 2018-11-24T10:58
By Rachel
at 2018-11-24T20:14
at 2018-11-24T20:14
By Edward Lewis
at 2018-11-26T20:57
at 2018-11-26T20:57
By Tristan Cohan
at 2018-11-29T04:15
at 2018-11-29T04:15
By Tristan Cohan
at 2018-11-29T17:42
at 2018-11-29T17:42
By Hedwig
at 2018-12-02T06:44
at 2018-12-02T06:44
By Tom
at 2018-12-05T14:25
at 2018-12-05T14:25
By Quintina
at 2018-12-06T04:54
at 2018-12-06T04:54
By Quintina
at 2018-12-07T20:38
at 2018-12-07T20:38
By Jack
at 2018-12-12T11:03
at 2018-12-12T11:03
By Vanessa
at 2018-12-15T10:03
at 2018-12-15T10:03
By Annie
at 2018-12-20T09:47
at 2018-12-20T09:47
By Odelette
at 2018-12-21T14:32
at 2018-12-21T14:32
By Kumar
at 2018-12-25T14:27
at 2018-12-25T14:27
By Donna
at 2018-12-29T01:43
at 2018-12-29T01:43
By Elma
at 2018-12-30T18:10
at 2018-12-30T18:10
By Adele
at 2019-01-03T19:58
at 2019-01-03T19:58
By Blanche
at 2019-01-04T14:24
at 2019-01-04T14:24
By Kyle
at 2019-01-06T21:17
at 2019-01-06T21:17
By Brianna
at 2019-01-10T15:26
at 2019-01-10T15:26
By Selena
at 2019-01-11T14:11
at 2019-01-11T14:11
By Kyle
at 2019-01-13T04:23
at 2019-01-13T04:23
By Isla
at 2019-01-14T13:43
at 2019-01-14T13:43
By Megan
at 2019-01-19T09:43
at 2019-01-19T09:43
By Zora
at 2019-01-20T01:10
at 2019-01-20T01:10
By Jacky
at 2019-01-20T12:28
at 2019-01-20T12:28
By Edward Lewis
at 2019-01-22T21:53
at 2019-01-22T21:53
By Elizabeth
at 2019-01-25T07:26
at 2019-01-25T07:26
By Todd Johnson
at 2019-01-27T03:03
at 2019-01-27T03:03
By Edwina
at 2019-01-30T21:57
at 2019-01-30T21:57
By Quintina
at 2019-02-01T05:02
at 2019-02-01T05:02
By Brianna
at 2019-02-02T16:08
at 2019-02-02T16:08
By Agatha
at 2019-02-06T00:12
at 2019-02-06T00:12
By Tracy
at 2019-02-08T17:22
at 2019-02-08T17:22
By Adele
at 2019-02-13T10:25
at 2019-02-13T10:25
By Dorothy
at 2019-02-17T18:43
at 2019-02-17T18:43
By Ursula
at 2019-02-20T20:07
at 2019-02-20T20:07
By Rae
at 2019-02-21T10:18
at 2019-02-21T10:18
By Margaret
at 2019-02-23T06:46
at 2019-02-23T06:46
By Lydia
at 2019-02-27T06:33
at 2019-02-27T06:33
By Poppy
at 2019-03-03T02:51
at 2019-03-03T02:51
By Ophelia
at 2019-03-05T05:40
at 2019-03-05T05:40
By Valerie
at 2019-03-09T07:32
at 2019-03-09T07:32
By Suhail Hany
at 2019-03-10T23:54
at 2019-03-10T23:54
By Agnes
at 2019-03-13T16:54
at 2019-03-13T16:54
By Brianna
at 2019-03-16T05:54
at 2019-03-16T05:54
By Andy
at 2019-03-16T08:11
at 2019-03-16T08:11
By Megan
at 2019-03-17T08:23
at 2019-03-17T08:23
By Elvira
at 2019-03-17T11:56
at 2019-03-17T11:56
By Cara
at 2019-03-21T03:02
at 2019-03-21T03:02
By George
at 2019-03-25T10:49
at 2019-03-25T10:49
By Emma
at 2019-03-26T18:12
at 2019-03-26T18:12
By Skylar Davis
at 2019-03-31T08:37
at 2019-03-31T08:37
By Jacob
at 2019-04-02T13:37
at 2019-04-02T13:37
By Anthony
at 2019-04-03T01:14
at 2019-04-03T01:14
By Vanessa
at 2019-04-03T21:27
at 2019-04-03T21:27
By Daph Bay
at 2019-04-04T05:08
at 2019-04-04T05:08
By Genevieve
at 2019-04-07T00:40
at 2019-04-07T00:40
By Adele
at 2019-04-08T07:25
at 2019-04-08T07:25
By Oscar
at 2019-04-12T19:43
at 2019-04-12T19:43
By Genevieve
at 2019-04-16T21:30
at 2019-04-16T21:30
By Agnes
at 2019-04-21T06:30
at 2019-04-21T06:30
By Aaliyah
at 2019-04-25T06:37
at 2019-04-25T06:37
By Skylar DavisLinda
at 2019-04-27T00:10
at 2019-04-27T00:10
By Catherine
at 2019-04-30T06:53
at 2019-04-30T06:53
By Kyle
at 2019-05-02T06:29
at 2019-05-02T06:29
By Erin
at 2019-05-04T10:39
at 2019-05-04T10:39
By Ethan
at 2019-05-05T08:01
at 2019-05-05T08:01
By Ursula
at 2019-05-06T23:54
at 2019-05-06T23:54
By Connor
at 2019-05-07T04:04
at 2019-05-07T04:04
By Sandy
at 2019-05-11T17:20
at 2019-05-11T17:20
By Erin
at 2019-05-15T06:42
at 2019-05-15T06:42
By Edward Lewis
at 2019-05-17T01:43
at 2019-05-17T01:43
By Eden
at 2019-05-19T14:12
at 2019-05-19T14:12
By Megan
at 2019-05-21T12:05
at 2019-05-21T12:05
By Regina
at 2019-05-24T11:49
at 2019-05-24T11:49
By Faithe
at 2019-05-27T12:28
at 2019-05-27T12:28
By Jack
at 2019-05-30T22:07
at 2019-05-30T22:07
By Dora
at 2019-06-01T08:34
at 2019-06-01T08:34
By Emily
at 2019-06-03T11:29
at 2019-06-03T11:29
By Christine
at 2019-06-07T02:31
at 2019-06-07T02:31
By Edward Lewis
at 2019-06-10T06:47
at 2019-06-10T06:47
By Edwina
at 2019-06-12T00:03
at 2019-06-12T00:03
By Selena
at 2019-06-16T01:55
at 2019-06-16T01:55
By Zora
at 2019-06-17T21:57
at 2019-06-17T21:57
By Skylar DavisLinda
at 2019-06-18T22:10
at 2019-06-18T22:10
By James
at 2019-06-23T08:37
at 2019-06-23T08:37
By Mia
at 2019-06-26T12:18
at 2019-06-26T12:18
By Bennie
at 2019-06-30T14:28
at 2019-06-30T14:28
By Edward Lewis
at 2019-07-04T13:29
at 2019-07-04T13:29
By Robert
at 2019-07-06T14:50
at 2019-07-06T14:50
By Harry
at 2019-07-11T06:41
at 2019-07-11T06:41
By Wallis
at 2019-07-12T12:28
at 2019-07-12T12:28
By Emma
at 2019-07-17T06:07
at 2019-07-17T06:07
By Kyle
at 2019-07-20T11:21
at 2019-07-20T11:21
By Freda
at 2019-07-24T06:47
at 2019-07-24T06:47
By Anonymous
at 2019-07-29T04:37
at 2019-07-29T04:37
By Kama
at 2019-07-31T18:34
at 2019-07-31T18:34
By Rae
at 2019-08-01T15:08
at 2019-08-01T15:08
By Lily
at 2019-08-02T18:12
at 2019-08-02T18:12
By Lily
at 2019-08-06T20:17
at 2019-08-06T20:17
By Valerie
at 2019-08-10T13:31
at 2019-08-10T13:31
By Rosalind
at 2019-08-10T20:58
at 2019-08-10T20:58
By Andy
at 2019-08-11T22:55
at 2019-08-11T22:55
By Margaret
at 2019-08-13T14:59
at 2019-08-13T14:59
By Bennie
at 2019-08-18T05:58
at 2019-08-18T05:58
By Linda
at 2019-08-22T09:57
at 2019-08-22T09:57
By Cara
at 2019-08-23T12:12
at 2019-08-23T12:12
By Suhail Hany
at 2019-08-28T03:15
at 2019-08-28T03:15
By Jacky
at 2019-08-30T01:18
at 2019-08-30T01:18
By Daph Bay
at 2019-08-30T13:53
at 2019-08-30T13:53
By Isabella
at 2019-09-03T10:21
at 2019-09-03T10:21
By Annie
at 2019-09-07T21:18
at 2019-09-07T21:18
By Ula
at 2019-09-11T10:38
at 2019-09-11T10:38
By Michael
at 2019-09-14T22:08
at 2019-09-14T22:08
By Noah
at 2019-09-16T04:08
at 2019-09-16T04:08
By Kama
at 2019-09-16T06:00
at 2019-09-16T06:00
By Bennie
at 2019-09-21T01:58
at 2019-09-21T01:58
By George
at 2019-09-25T03:27
at 2019-09-25T03:27
By Kumar
at 2019-09-26T07:44
at 2019-09-26T07:44
By Donna
at 2019-09-27T10:35
at 2019-09-27T10:35
By Mia
at 2019-09-29T00:58
at 2019-09-29T00:58
By Sarah
at 2019-10-02T06:17
at 2019-10-02T06:17
By Hedy
at 2019-10-06T21:43
at 2019-10-06T21:43
By Hazel
at 2019-10-10T15:16
at 2019-10-10T15:16
By Sierra Rose
at 2019-10-13T20:12
at 2019-10-13T20:12
By Delia
at 2019-10-15T09:30
at 2019-10-15T09:30
By Candice
at 2019-10-16T23:55
at 2019-10-16T23:55
By Valerie
at 2019-10-21T18:34
at 2019-10-21T18:34
By Frederica
at 2019-10-25T09:49
at 2019-10-25T09:49
By Olivia
at 2019-10-27T08:40
at 2019-10-27T08:40
By Hamiltion
at 2019-10-31T00:13
at 2019-10-31T00:13
By Connor
at 2019-11-02T00:07
at 2019-11-02T00:07
By Odelette
at 2019-11-05T01:25
at 2019-11-05T01:25
By Candice
at 2019-11-05T13:56
at 2019-11-05T13:56
By Mason
at 2019-11-08T02:18
at 2019-11-08T02:18
By Donna
at 2019-11-10T10:50
at 2019-11-10T10:50
By Michael
at 2019-11-10T19:37
at 2019-11-10T19:37
By Harry
at 2019-11-13T01:13
at 2019-11-13T01:13
By Oliver
at 2019-11-16T13:31
at 2019-11-16T13:31
By Ophelia
at 2019-11-17T05:13
at 2019-11-17T05:13
By Ursula
at 2019-11-17T18:02
at 2019-11-17T18:02
By Adele
at 2019-11-20T20:13
at 2019-11-20T20:13
By Freda
at 2019-11-22T14:53
at 2019-11-22T14:53
By Carol
at 2019-11-23T17:26
at 2019-11-23T17:26
By Cara
at 2019-11-24T17:27
at 2019-11-24T17:27
By Sandy
at 2019-11-28T22:06
at 2019-11-28T22:06
By Anthony
at 2019-12-03T20:46
at 2019-12-03T20:46
By Harry
at 2019-12-07T08:43
at 2019-12-07T08:43
By Freda
at 2019-12-11T15:26
at 2019-12-11T15:26
By Rosalind
at 2019-12-12T03:51
at 2019-12-12T03:51
By Edith
at 2019-12-14T03:31
at 2019-12-14T03:31
By Elvira
at 2019-12-17T19:45
at 2019-12-17T19:45
By Jake
at 2019-12-18T13:56
at 2019-12-18T13:56
By Mary
at 2019-12-19T22:47
at 2019-12-19T22:47
By Tom
at 2019-12-23T20:24
at 2019-12-23T20:24
By Genevieve
at 2019-12-25T18:43
at 2019-12-25T18:43
By Suhail Hany
at 2019-12-28T09:46
at 2019-12-28T09:46
By Una
at 2019-12-31T08:45
at 2019-12-31T08:45
By Carol
at 2019-12-31T14:59
at 2019-12-31T14:59
By Anonymous
at 2020-01-02T12:37
at 2020-01-02T12:37
By Gary
at 2020-01-03T03:06
at 2020-01-03T03:06
By Joe
at 2020-01-04T07:04
at 2020-01-04T07:04
By David
at 2020-01-07T00:28
at 2020-01-07T00:28
By Ina
at 2020-01-07T05:55
at 2020-01-07T05:55
By Agatha
at 2020-01-10T10:45
at 2020-01-10T10:45
By Genevieve
at 2020-01-12T05:07
at 2020-01-12T05:07
By Hazel
at 2020-01-13T22:17
at 2020-01-13T22:17
By Edith
at 2020-01-14T23:45
at 2020-01-14T23:45
By Kyle
at 2020-01-17T12:03
at 2020-01-17T12:03
By Ula
at 2020-01-18T00:29
at 2020-01-18T00:29
By Iris
at 2020-01-21T17:14
at 2020-01-21T17:14
By Queena
at 2020-01-24T17:34
at 2020-01-24T17:34
By Odelette
at 2020-01-25T20:48
at 2020-01-25T20:48
By Zanna
at 2020-01-25T23:40
at 2020-01-25T23:40
By Zanna
at 2020-01-26T09:14
at 2020-01-26T09:14
By Poppy
at 2020-01-30T19:11
at 2020-01-30T19:11
By Christine
at 2020-02-03T21:08
at 2020-02-03T21:08
By Odelette
at 2020-02-06T10:09
at 2020-02-06T10:09
By Skylar DavisLinda
at 2020-02-06T19:21
at 2020-02-06T19:21
By David
at 2020-02-07T17:11
at 2020-02-07T17:11
By Todd Johnson
at 2020-02-09T05:25
at 2020-02-09T05:25
By Olivia
at 2020-02-13T00:56
at 2020-02-13T00:56
By Gary
at 2020-02-13T23:46
at 2020-02-13T23:46
By Todd Johnson
at 2020-02-14T09:56
at 2020-02-14T09:56
By Carol
at 2020-02-17T04:54
at 2020-02-17T04:54
By Hamiltion
at 2020-02-19T19:39
at 2020-02-19T19:39
By Faithe
at 2020-02-22T05:29
at 2020-02-22T05:29
By Carolina Franco
at 2020-02-25T03:08
at 2020-02-25T03:08
By Olga
at 2020-02-25T10:56
at 2020-02-25T10:56
By Annie
at 2020-02-28T02:33
at 2020-02-28T02:33
By Kama
at 2020-02-29T01:53
at 2020-02-29T01:53
By Bennie
at 2020-03-04T21:54
at 2020-03-04T21:54
By Bethany
at 2020-03-05T17:23
at 2020-03-05T17:23
By Selena
at 2020-03-05T20:57
at 2020-03-05T20:57
By Isabella
at 2020-03-08T16:41
at 2020-03-08T16:41
By Wallis
at 2020-03-10T17:10
at 2020-03-10T17:10
By Blanche
at 2020-03-12T21:29
at 2020-03-12T21:29
By Steve
at 2020-03-15T23:57
at 2020-03-15T23:57
By Robert
at 2020-03-17T00:43
at 2020-03-17T00:43
By Zenobia
at 2020-03-19T13:18
at 2020-03-19T13:18
By Bethany
at 2020-03-23T11:13
at 2020-03-23T11:13
By Andy
at 2020-03-25T13:03
at 2020-03-25T13:03
By Genevieve
at 2020-03-27T11:57
at 2020-03-27T11:57
By Zanna
at 2020-03-27T14:37
at 2020-03-27T14:37
By Jake
at 2020-03-30T22:28
at 2020-03-30T22:28
By Noah
at 2020-04-02T06:27
at 2020-04-02T06:27
By Agatha
at 2020-04-04T07:46
at 2020-04-04T07:46
By Donna
at 2020-04-07T14:14
at 2020-04-07T14:14
By Joe
at 2020-04-10T05:23
at 2020-04-10T05:23
By Daniel
at 2020-04-10T07:24
at 2020-04-10T07:24
By Tracy
at 2020-04-15T00:59
at 2020-04-15T00:59
By Isla
at 2020-04-15T05:31
at 2020-04-15T05:31
By Dorothy
at 2020-04-19T18:32
at 2020-04-19T18:32
By Hedy
at 2020-04-21T19:13
at 2020-04-21T19:13
By Necoo
at 2020-04-24T05:14
at 2020-04-24T05:14
By Donna
at 2020-04-25T17:07
at 2020-04-25T17:07
By Lucy
at 2020-04-25T19:24
at 2020-04-25T19:24
By Steve
at 2020-04-29T13:05
at 2020-04-29T13:05
By Steve
at 2020-05-01T23:29
at 2020-05-01T23:29
By Genevieve
at 2020-05-05T23:25
at 2020-05-05T23:25
By Edward Lewis
at 2020-05-09T22:07
at 2020-05-09T22:07
By Zora
at 2020-05-12T13:28
at 2020-05-12T13:28
By Una
at 2020-05-15T07:59
at 2020-05-15T07:59
By Franklin
at 2020-05-16T03:36
at 2020-05-16T03:36
By Quintina
at 2020-05-18T15:01
at 2020-05-18T15:01
By Frederic
at 2020-05-23T08:59
at 2020-05-23T08:59
By James
at 2020-05-27T19:51
at 2020-05-27T19:51
By Zora
at 2020-05-30T07:46
at 2020-05-30T07:46
By Thomas
at 2020-05-31T13:45
at 2020-05-31T13:45
By Brianna
at 2020-05-31T17:14
at 2020-05-31T17:14
By Freda
at 2020-06-01T04:56
at 2020-06-01T04:56
By Catherine
at 2020-06-05T13:17
at 2020-06-05T13:17
By Gilbert
at 2020-06-05T21:34
at 2020-06-05T21:34
By Thomas
at 2020-06-06T15:18
at 2020-06-06T15:18
By Harry
at 2020-06-11T08:54
at 2020-06-11T08:54
By Oliver
at 2020-06-13T03:43
at 2020-06-13T03:43
By Thomas
at 2020-06-15T17:56
at 2020-06-15T17:56
By James
at 2020-06-17T00:11
at 2020-06-17T00:11
By Skylar Davis
at 2020-06-21T12:23
at 2020-06-21T12:23
By Andy
at 2020-06-26T10:26
at 2020-06-26T10:26
By Damian
at 2020-06-27T14:57
at 2020-06-27T14:57
By Mia
at 2020-06-28T20:38
at 2020-06-28T20:38
By Xanthe
at 2020-07-03T05:48
at 2020-07-03T05:48
By Margaret
at 2020-07-07T08:14
at 2020-07-07T08:14
By Genevieve
at 2020-07-11T14:56
at 2020-07-11T14:56
By Daniel
at 2020-07-16T12:30
at 2020-07-16T12:30
By Xanthe
at 2020-07-20T21:14
at 2020-07-20T21:14
By Queena
at 2020-07-24T23:41
at 2020-07-24T23:41
By Oscar
at 2020-07-25T16:30
at 2020-07-25T16:30
By Kama
at 2020-07-25T18:52
at 2020-07-25T18:52
By Linda
at 2020-07-30T18:29
at 2020-07-30T18:29
By Cara
at 2020-08-03T03:17
at 2020-08-03T03:17
By Regina
at 2020-08-06T20:11
at 2020-08-06T20:11
By Catherine
at 2020-08-10T23:13
at 2020-08-10T23:13
By Ina
at 2020-08-11T22:54
at 2020-08-11T22:54
By Noah
at 2020-08-15T00:09
at 2020-08-15T00:09
By Steve
at 2020-08-16T06:09
at 2020-08-16T06:09
By George
at 2020-08-20T15:14
at 2020-08-20T15:14
By Vanessa
at 2020-08-25T07:57
at 2020-08-25T07:57
By Jessica
at 2020-08-25T09:47
at 2020-08-25T09:47
By Tracy
at 2020-08-25T18:28
at 2020-08-25T18:28
By Heather
at 2020-08-26T01:35
at 2020-08-26T01:35
By Ina
at 2020-08-26T05:50
at 2020-08-26T05:50
By Gilbert
at 2020-08-27T02:06
at 2020-08-27T02:06
By Olga
at 2020-08-27T04:34
at 2020-08-27T04:34
By Zanna
at 2020-08-31T11:24
at 2020-08-31T11:24
By Zenobia
at 2020-09-05T02:39
at 2020-09-05T02:39
By Megan
at 2020-09-07T05:19
at 2020-09-07T05:19
By Puput
at 2020-09-09T04:40
at 2020-09-09T04:40
By Gary
at 2020-09-12T10:09
at 2020-09-12T10:09
By Elizabeth
at 2020-09-16T09:37
at 2020-09-16T09:37
By Lauren
at 2020-09-18T19:15
at 2020-09-18T19:15
By Puput
at 2020-09-20T03:37
at 2020-09-20T03:37
By Lauren
at 2020-09-21T09:13
at 2020-09-21T09:13
Related Posts
德國收養法規
By Catherine
at 2017-06-23T03:50
at 2017-06-23T03:50
私人土地發生車禍,有關民事賠償問題?
By Emily
at 2017-06-23T01:19
at 2017-06-23T01:19
車禍和解書 拋棄權利
By Barb Cronin
at 2017-06-23T01:02
at 2017-06-23T01:02
遇到惡劣包商(台中)，後續處理問題
By Isabella
at 2017-06-23T00:09
at 2017-06-23T00:09
請問：「佛性」和「覺性」意思一樣麼？
By Poppy
at 2017-06-22T23:34
at 2017-06-22T23:34